🍷 Wine basics

Why a wine's price doesn't tell the whole story

In my notes, a wine under €15 got the same rating as a classified growth four times the price. What price actually measures, and what it doesn't.

Par Joëlle· Mis à jour le November 12, 2026· 3 min de lecture

When I reread my notes with the purchase prices next to them, one thing jumps out: price predicts almost nothing about my rating.

A Saint-Julien classified growth, around €60: 4 out of 4. An organic white from the Côtes du Rhône, under €15: 4 out of 4 too, "Very fruity, fairly dry. I like it a lot". And a natural red a bit more expensive than that white: 1 out of 4, "Not my thing at all".

Price says something. But not what you think.

What a bottle really pays for

The price of a wine adds up many things that have nothing to do with your enjoyment:

  • the terroir and its rarity: a hectare in Burgundy or in Saint-Julien costs a fortune;
  • the yield: less fruit per vine costs more;
  • the labour: hand harvesting, organic, biodynamic;
  • the ageing: new oak barrels, years of keeping at the estate;
  • the reputation: the name of the château, the critics' scores;
  • the channel: the wine shop, the supermarket, the restaurant.

All of that is real. But none of it guarantees you will like the wine.

Where price really matters

Price is not useless.

Below a certain threshold, it becomes hard to make a careful wine. Very cheap wines are often standardised.

For ageing, wines made to age cost more, because they take more work and more material. My Saint-Julien classified growth, rated "A bit young but wow", is a wine to wait years for.

For consistency, a reputable estate gets it wrong less often.

Why a cheaper bottle can please you more

Because price often rewards qualities you don't necessarily like.

Expensive wines are often more powerful, oakier, more concentrated. If you like that, great. Personally, I prefer light, fruity wines that aren't too strong in alcohol. A good share of my 4 out of 4 wines are simple wines, from Beaujolais, the Île de Ré, Savoie.

A Roussette de Savoie at a gentle price: "Very nice, great discovery". A white Beaujolais Villages recommended by my wine merchant: "Great discovery. Great recommendation". Those are the bottles I buy again.

The best wine is the one that suits you

The real trap is believing that paying more means taking less risk. That is only true if the style matches what you like.

Before you move up in price, know your style. Once you know you like mineral whites or light reds, you can look for the best wines in that style, at every price.

Finding the bottles you really enjoyed

It is by rating my wines with their price that I saw all this. In veeni, the purchase price stays private, visible only to me, next to my rating. Over time, I see which wines gave me pleasure, and how much they cost me.

It is the best way to stop paying for a label.

In short

Price pays for terroir, labour, reputation. Not your enjoyment. Know your style, rate your wines with their price, and you will soon see that some of your best bottles are not the most expensive.

FAQ

Is an expensive wine better?+

It is often more carefully made, more complex, better able to age. But "better for you" depends mostly on your style.

What budget for a good everyday wine?+

At a wine shop, between €10 and €20 you can find many lovely wines. Ask for a wine in the style you like, rather than an appellation.

Should you trust medals?+

They say a jury liked the wine one day. It is a clue, not a guarantee that you will like it.

PartagerXLinkedInFacebook

Guides liés